Assessment FAQ

Good assessment always starts with well-formed questions. I will help you think through what it is that you really want to know about your child or yourself. Then, we can think about what kinds of testing or other observation would be helpful in figuring it out. The process is a lot like science: we generate hypotheses that might explain what we already know, and then we think about what kinds of controlled observations might help us distinguish between different hypotheses. Sometimes, as we refine the questions, we'll find that formal assessment isn't really the right way to answer them, saving you time and money.

Testing cannot tell us about some hypothetical magic number tattooed in a kid’s DNA. Although real differences between children absolutely exist, what testing shows us is a snapshot in time: how this person did on this test on that day. Particularly for the unusual folks I typically assess, the scores are only part of the analysis. I am looking not just at what the final numbers were, but also at how the person got there: how they approach different kinds of tasks, what kinds of strategies and skills they use spontaneously, how those skills might compare with classroom expectations, what they do when things are too easy or too hard, and so on. That information is an important adjunct to the numerical scores, because it helps put everything in real-world context.

Why might I want my child assessed?

Usually, people who seek me out for assessment are asking one of two major types of questions:

• You have a child who is obviously bright. They might have hit a number of developmental milestones early, or taught themselves to read at a young age, or in some other way seem to be highly intelligent. You're gifted yourself, and you know that these things tend to run in families. There might not really be a problem right now, but you're curious, or you're hoping to avoid a problem in the future. You might be trying to figure out what your child's strengths and weaknesses are, and what kinds of educational approaches would be most appropriate; or you might be hoping to get hard data that might qualify the child for some kind of services, or that will inform your discussions with someone else, such as a teacher or administrator.
• A child, adolescent, or young adult constantly seems to draw the question, "You're so smart, so why can't you...?" Many bright-to-gifted individuals with "stealth disabilities" are able to manage reasonably well in school, particularly in the younger grades, but struggle more and more as the curricular and organizational demands of school build up. Motivation often suffers. Or they might continue to try harder and harder, but experience less and less success and joy in learning. Parents, teachers, students, and professors might be starting to argue over what the meaning of what they are observing -- is the kid just "not that smart," or just "not working hard enough," are the parents just "too pushy," are the educators just "not getting it"? Would formal accommodations, curricular modifications, or special education strategies be appropriate? Could the student learn some new study strategies that might make the difference? Assessment can help us figure out what is really going on and what could be done about it. Sometimes, what we find surprises everyone.

I will provide you with a comprehensive report, written in readable, nontechnical language, that answers your questions as clearly and completely as possible. My clients tend to be educated adults who are curious not just about the scores, but in gaining a more complete understanding of their child’s or their own learning profile. I include information about how the individual approached different kinds of tasks, what seemed to work well for them, what they might benefit from learning, how they can capitalize on their strengths and shore up their weaknesses, and what real-world teaching methods would be most likely to help. You will also have a chance to sit down with me in person and go over the report, so that I can address any questions you might have.

It is also possible that you might be interested in sharing what we find with a school, an organization that provides services for gifted children, a university disability office, or someone else. I will make sure to present information in a form that will answer the questions those audiences have; if appropriate, I will consult with them ahead of time to ensure that their questions will be fully addressed.

We may decide together that you may also have an audience who needs only the most important ideas from the main report, presented in a short precis that they can read and understand quickly.

Furthermore, many kids, particularly older children and adolescents, benefit strongly from having developmentally-appropriate aspects of the assessment results presented in language they can understand, in a letter or a face-to-face discussion. (Having taught middle school really helps me here.)

The fact is, kids get labelled all the time. Unfortunately, the labels tend to be things like “show-off,” “lazy,” “unmotivated,” “pain in the neck,” and so on. The purpose of assessment is to help us ensure that the descriptive language that we use about kids is accurate and compassionate, and that it helps us know what to do in order to support their growth. I do not make diagnostic statements one way or the other, but if I feel that it would be to your child’s benefit, I will refer you to someone who can make a clear diagnosis.

I have a wide variety of cognitive and academic tests at my disposal. Some of them “look like school,” while others are used to break down learning and cognition into component parts that can be looked at individually. I focus the testing on the specific questions we’re asking and my best guesses at what the answers might be. I will often adapt my testing plan on the fly, based upon what I observe during the testing process.

Actually, although most kids are a bit apprehensive before we get started, they generally find that it ends up being interesting, and even fun. It's a bit like detective work -- I feel strongly that we get the most useful information when I can engage your child directly in a collaborative process. Part of my job is to build rapport with them, and part of what I'm observing is how they adjust to the parts of the process that are less than fun. I explain it to them in developmentally-appropriate language. I do generally use the word "test," but I help them understand that these tests are not like the tests in school, in that you cannot fail them: our goal is to find some tasks that are too easy, some that are too hard, and some that are just right. I am also always happy to answer kids' questions before, during, or after testing, and to listen to their own insights into the process.

Many people's giftedness or learning problems have psychological issues intertwined with them. I am not yet licensed to conduct psychological assessments; this is part of my lifelong work-in-progress. If I suspect from the history that there may be a serious psychological disorder complicating their learning process, I will suggest that you have the initial evaluation done by a psychologist. I am happy to make referrals to colleagues I know well and who I think will be able to answer your questions. I am also happy to collaborate with psychologists in conducting integrated evaluations, to consult to them regarding the evaluation of possibly twice-exceptional clients, or to follow up their evaluations with supplemental analysis of unanswered academic or cognitive questions.

If, while I am doing an assessment, I notice signs of a possible unrecognized psychological, cognitive, developmental, or sensory disorder, I will tell you what I observed, document my concerns in the report, and make recommendations for further evaluation by appropriate professionals.

That really depends upon the complexity of the question. Once we figure out what your questions are and develop a rough sense of the testing plan, I will quote you a flat fee for the entire assessment process, including my history-taking and other information-gathering, review of work samples, the testing itself, analysis and preparation of the report, and a consultation with you once the report is complete. If appropriate, I might give you some different options and a sense of the pros and cons of each one. In any case, you will know how much you are going to pay before we begin.

If what you need is just a score, and you are not interested in the rest of the analysis and recommendations, you can probably have the testing done more cheaply in other venues, and I won’t be shy about telling you that. In fact, a sizable fraction of parents who contact me seeking assessment hear that I don’t think their child needs assessment at all at that time.

If you have any other questions about the assessment process, please don't hesitate to contact me.